Why It Matters

Federal law draws a fact-specific line, rather than a bright-line distinction, between agency policy messaging and partisan political messaging, according to a new Congressional Research Service (CRS) report. The Hatch Act and annual appropriations provisions prohibiting "publicity or propaganda" both constrain official communications, and the report says determining whether a message crosses the line "may require a fact-intensive inquiry." ​

The report bears on communications by the Trump administration and Congress' oversight of them. Under the Hatch Act, the Merit Systems Protection Board can impose removal, a reduction in grade, debarment from federal employment for up to five years, suspension, reprimand, or civil fines on federal employees. Violations of the publicity or propaganda provisions can also violate the Antideficiency Act, which requires agencies to report violations to the president and Congress.

The Big Picture

The Hatch Act, first enacted in 1939, covers nearly all federal civilian executive branch employees but exempts the president and vice president. The report said communications that discuss, promote, or defend an administration's policy positions generally do not implicate the law. Campaign-related political activity does.

The U.S. Office of Special Counsel (OSC) weighs four factors: whether the message had a clear, contemporaneous non-electoral purpose; its timing relative to an election; its tone; and the context of its dissemination. OSC has advised that "neutrally framed" references to a political party incidental to an ongoing legislative or operational dispute are unlikely to constitute prohibited political activity. References that are "gratuitous, made close to an election, and framed as an attack on a party" are more likely to do so.

The OSC also treats messages equivalent to a "closing argument" for a candidate as potentially prohibited political activity. It cited an op-ed by a Cabinet secretary, published the day before a presidential election, that focused almost entirely on the incumbent candidate's accomplishments. In a separate announcement, OSC said it issued an assessment and advisory on Sept. 25 about partisan agency communications during the 2025 government shutdown. OSC concluded that disciplinary action was not warranted because federal employees had reasonably relied on its earlier guidance concerning references to political parties.

The appropriations restriction works differently. The Government Accountability Office (GAO) has identified three prohibited categories of communications: self-aggrandizement, covert propaganda and purely partisan materials. GAO has said a violation requires an agency justification "so palpably erroneous as to be unreasonable," as explained in decision B-331262.

Advertisement

The report said OSC may struggle to identify the employees behind a message, and it "can neither enforce its own subpoenas nor compel agencies to respond to its investigative requests." OSC also lacks authority to initiate disciplinary proceedings against certain high-level officials, limiting its ability to pursue discipline against an agency head responsible for partisan messaging.

The report notes that at least one federal court has reviewed an Administrative Procedure Act claim involving a publicity or propaganda provision. That court granted a temporary restraining order directing an agency to stop running advertisements challenged as purely partisan. Separately, the Campaign Legal Center announced that a federal court issued a temporary restraining order on Oct. 11 blocking taxpayer-funded partisan political advertisements for 14 days.

The Bottom Line

With no bright-line rule, a disputed agency communication would be assessed on its own timing, tone, purpose and context to determine whether it constitutes prohibited political activity or an improper use of federal funds.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article