Why It Matters
Hundreds of coal mining sites across the United States remain unreclaimed despite having stopped producing coal, according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report released Nov. 12.
The report found that more than half of the nation's 5,000-plus permitted coal mining operations have had no associated production since 2000, raising concerns that abandoned or inactive sites could pose environmental and public health risks while preventing communities from putting the land to other uses.
The findings also raise questions about the federal government's ability to oversee mine reclamation after the agency responsible for enforcing mining regulations lost 35% of its workforce.
The Big Picture
The Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act of 1977 established the Office of Surface Mining Reclamation and Enforcement (OSMRE) within the Department of the Interior to oversee coal mining operations and ensure that disturbed land is eventually restored.
Under the law, coal mine operators must reclaim land affected by mining to reduce environmental damage and public health risks. However, GAO found that hundreds of sites remain unreclaimed, even as coal production has declined nationwide. As of spring 2025, more than 5,000 coal mining operations held permits across 25 states and four Tribes. Most permits have had no associated coal production since 2000, while about 35% of all permits are associated with sites undergoing reclamation.
The report warned that delays in reclaiming inactive mines can expose communities to environmental, health, and safety hazards while preventing land from returning to productive uses, potentially harming local economies. GAO also identified significant weaknesses in the federal government's oversight of reclamation efforts, including staffing shortages, inadequate performance tracking, and failures to provide Congress with required reports.
Between 2024 and May, OSMRE's workforce fell from 408 to 265 employees, a 35% reduction driven primarily by deferred resignations, a federal hiring freeze and restructuring within the Interior Department. Agency officials acknowledged that the staffing cuts have affected oversight activities. However, Interior officials told GAO that the department had not conducted strategic workforce planning before reducing staffing levels and had not evaluated OSMRE's future operational capacity as of August.
GAO warned that the reductions could undermine the agency's ability to enforce mining regulations and oversee reclamation projects, particularly without assessing the staffing and expertise needed to fulfill its responsibilities. The agency also found that OSMRE lacks adequate tools to measure how quickly inactive coal mines are reclaimed.
Although OSMRE uses four performance measures to evaluate its progress, none tracks how long operators take to reclaim mines after production ends. Without that information, federal regulators may struggle to identify sites that pose the greatest environmental risks or could create financial liabilities for the government.
GAO also found that OSMRE has failed to publish its legally required annual performance report since 2020. Agency officials attributed the lapse to competing priorities. The missing reports have left Congress without regular nationwide updates on the agency's reclamation efforts, limiting lawmakers' ability to evaluate its performance and hold officials accountable.
The Bottom Line
GAO issued four recommendations to the Interior Department to strengthen federal oversight of coal mine reclamation. All four remain open. The recommendations call for the department to assess OSMRE's staffing needs, improve the timeliness of its reviews of proposed changes to state and tribal regulatory programs, establish measures tracking how long mine reclamation takes, and resume publishing its annual performance reports.
Interior did not provide comments on the report, leaving its position on the recommendations unclear. GAO has not identified implementation dates and said it will update the recommendations' status after confirming what actions the department has taken.
The report warns that without better tracking and oversight, federal officials may be unable to determine which inactive mines pose the greatest environmental and financial risks or whether reclamation efforts are progressing quickly enough. GAO also emphasized that failing to publish annual reports deprives Congress of the information it needs to assess nationwide reclamation efforts and hold the agency accountable.
The proposed performance measures would track the time between a mine's last production and its progress toward reclamation, providing regulators with a clearer picture of how long disturbed lands remain unused and potentially hazardous.
A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article