Why it matters:

The Senate Judiciary Committee examined six district-court nominations on Sept. 16, while a broader dispute over the Justice Department surfaced in opening remarks.

The big picture:

The hearing, titled “Hearings To Examine Certain Pending Nominations,” featured Daniel Ballou, Richard Bennett, Courtney Coker, Trevor Pemberton, Kyle Reardon and Zachary West.

The nominees were identified for the Eastern District of Kentucky, Southern District of Texas, Northern District of Texas, Northern District of Oklahoma, District of Alaska and Eastern District of Oklahoma, respectively. Chuck Grassley (R-IA) was identified as the committee chair, and Dick Durbin (D-IL) was identified as the committee's ranking member.

Grassley said two nominees had served in the military. He also said two-thirds of the nominees already had judicial experience, while Durbin said three had been longtime federal prosecutors.

What they’re saying:

Durbin used his opening remarks to challenge the Justice Department’s credibility in court and its election-related actions. He said judges in at least 90 cases from January 2025 through March 2026 stated they did not trust department representations to the court.

  • “did not trust Justice Department representations,” Durbin said.
  • “had not been fully constituted,” Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK) said of Alaska’s district court.
  • “nearly 25 years,” Grassley said of Ballou’s time as a Kentucky state judge.

Durbin said the Justice Department sent threatening letters to at least 30 top election officials and sued 30 states for unredacted voter lists. He said the department had not won a case in that effort and had lost 23.

Grassley highlighted the nominees’ experience. He said Pemberton had served as a trial judge and appellate judge in Oklahoma, while Bennett and Reardon were federal magistrate judges in Texas and Alaska.

Murkowski focused on Reardon’s qualifications. She said he had served as an Alaska magistrate judge since 2021, handling more than 3,000 criminal matters and almost 500 civil matters.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article