Why It Matters

Scientists may be able to determine the age of fish and other marine animals without killing them, potentially improving how federal agencies monitor fisheries and protect vulnerable species, according to a Congressional Research Service (CRS) report. ​

The emerging technique, known as DNA methylation analysis, could provide a less invasive alternative to traditional methods that often require sacrificing animals to examine their bones, scales, shells or other hard body parts. Researchers say the approach could be particularly valuable for studying threatened, endangered, and protected species, although CRS has not identified instances of federal agencies using it in marine resource surveys or assessments.

The Big Picture

DNA methylation involves chemical changes to DNA that can be used to estimate an animal's biological age. Researchers have found that methylation patterns change as organisms grow older, allowing scientists to develop molecular tools known as epigenetic clocks to estimate age.

Studies suggest the technique can also determine the sex of certain fish without killing them. Researchers have developed age estimates for species including Atlantic cod, cownose rays, deepwater scorpionfish and European seabass, raising the possibility that DNA testing could eventually replace some invasive sampling methods used in fisheries management. However, scientists say more research is needed to determine whether the technique works consistently across species with different body sizes and life histories. Environmental conditions, including temperature, oxygen availability, salinity and diet, may also influence DNA methylation patterns and affect the accuracy of age estimates.

The technology could have applications beyond commercial fisheries. Studies suggest that small tissue samples can be used to estimate the ages of whales, dolphins, seals, sea lions, walruses and polar bears. Researchers have also explored its use in sea turtles, although determining an animal's exact age since hatching remains challenging.

The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's National Marine Fisheries Service has already made progress incorporating environmental DNA, or eDNA, into research on marine populations. Unlike DNA methylation, which examines chemical changes associated with aging, eDNA lets scientists detect genetic material organisms leave behind in water and other environments. The report notes that molecular techniques could complement traditional fisheries surveys rather than replace them entirely, particularly while researchers work to establish their reliability across different species.

Advertisement

Congress has also shown interest in expanding the use of genetic technologies in fisheries management. S. 5273, sponsored by Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), would direct the National Marine Fisheries Service to evaluate and validate eDNA and other emerging technologies for federal fish stock assessments. Depending on how the legislation is interpreted and implemented, those technologies could include DNA methylation.

Lawmakers could also consider whether molecular testing is more cost-effective than conventional surveys, whether federal agencies have sufficient resources to adopt it, and whether the results are reliable enough to inform fisheries management decisions. The Trump administration has separately called for modernizing federal fisheries data collection. Executive Order 14430, signed Sept. 17 and published Sept. 22, directs federal agencies to improve data collection and modernize management of recreational saltwater fishing.

The Bottom Line

DNA methylation could give fisheries managers another way to estimate the age and health of marine populations without killing the animals they study. But researchers still need to determine how accurately the technique works across species and environmental conditions before it can become a dependable tool for federal stock assessments. Congress could help that transition by directing agencies to evaluate emerging technologies and deciding whether to incorporate them into fisheries management.

S. 5273 was introduced Aug. 6 and referred to the Senate Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee. It has not advanced beyond the introduced stage, leaving any additional requirements for federal agencies dependent on further congressional action.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article