Why It Matters
The Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) identified deficiencies in medical care in 45% of natural deaths in federal custody during fiscal 2024, with some of those failures contributing to prisoners' deaths, according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report released Nov. 16.
The findings raise concerns about medical care in federal prisons, where approximately 3,000 people died of natural causes between fiscal 2016 and 2025. Investigators identified problems including delayed medical appointments outside prison facilities, failures to order necessary medical tests and inadequate emergency responses. The report also found that BOP has failed to consistently track whether problems uncovered in death investigations have been corrected, potentially allowing deficiencies in medical care to persist.
The Big Picture
BOP is responsible for the care and custody of approximately 155,000 incarcerated people. Federal law enforcement agencies reported nearly 4,000 deaths in custody between fiscal 2016 and 2023, with BOP accounting for 85% of those deaths.
BOP policy requires staff to investigate every death in its facilities, excluding legal executions, and notify the deceased person's emergency contacts and next of kin. Staff must also share information about the circumstances surrounding the death. However, GAO found significant gaps in how the agency documents notifications, communicates with families, and follows up on problems identified during investigations.
BOP could not determine how many emergency contacts and family members had been notified of deaths because it did not require staff to document those notifications or management to monitor compliance. In May, the agency began requiring staff to document attempts to notify next of kin, but it still does not require documentation of attempts to reach emergency contacts or management oversight of the process.
Investigators also found that BOP has never clearly defined what information staff must provide when explaining the circumstances of a prisoner's death. As a result, employees have inconsistent understandings of what they must disclose, and families do not always receive information even when it is available or becomes available later.
The failures extend to BOP's internal investigations. Although the agency reviews deaths in custody to identify deficiencies in medical care and other institutional problems, it does not consistently record the recommendations resulting from those investigations or track whether individual prisons implement corrective measures. Without that information, federal officials may struggle to identify recurring problems across facilities, determine whether corrective actions are effective or prevent similar deaths in the future.
The Bottom Line
GAO issued 13 recommendations to the Department of Justice, all directed at improving BOP's handling of deaths in custody, communication with families, and oversight of medical care deficiencies. All 13 recommendations remain open, although BOP agreed with them.
The recommendations call for clearer procedures for notifying families, documenting and monitoring those communications, defining what information must be disclosed about deaths and helping relatives obtain medical records. GAO also urged BOP to address delays in mortality reviews, track whether investigative recommendations are implemented, strengthen nationwide analysis of deaths in custody, and improve procedures for requesting autopsies when state or local authorities deny them.
The findings highlight consequences that extend beyond the agency's administrative failures. GAO warned that inadequate monitoring of family notifications increases the risk that relatives will never receive critical information about how their loved ones died. The agency also warned that failing to document and address deficiencies uncovered in death investigations limits BOP's ability to improve medical care and could increase the federal government's legal liability.
Without stronger oversight, the problems identified in federal prison death investigations could remain unresolved, leaving incarcerated people vulnerable to preventable failures in medical care and families without answers about their relatives' deaths.
A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article