Why It Matters
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has not been transparent about how it administers preparedness grants, according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report on grant transparency and communication published Nov. 12. FEMA oversees 13 preparedness grant programs totaling $2.9 billion for fiscal year 2026, intended to help state and local governments, nonprofits and other organizations prevent, prepare for, and respond to terrorism and disasters.
The Big Picture
Following the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, FEMA, within the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), implemented a series of preparedness grants to address terrorist threats. The programs cover threats such as mass shootings and attacks on transit systems or ports, funding training, emergency exercises, equipment, planning, and communications. FEMA also awards grants to prepare for major events, including the FIFA World Cup and the 2028 Summer Olympics.
In 2025, DHS terminated grants and paused funding, delaying disbursements to recipients. In April 2025, a U.S. district court ordered FEMA to stop delaying disbursements while litigation continued. DHS also imposed conditions on grant awards, including requirements that recipients cooperate with federal immigration enforcement. A federal district court prohibited DHS from enforcing the 2025 immigration-related conditions, but the department attached similar conditions to subsequent awards. Litigation over those requirements remained ongoing as of November.
GAO's previous investigations identified transparency problems across several grant programs. In July 2023, GAO found that FEMA's 2021 funding notice for transit security grants inaccurately described how it would score applications, including how it would evaluate projects for reducing risks. FEMA also did not consistently award funding to the highest-scoring applications. In September 2025, GAO found that FEMA's port security grants announcement failed to disclose all evaluation criteria or explain how it weighted them to determine project scores.
Communication with grant recipients has also been inconsistent. In January 2024, GAO reported that FEMA failed to notify stakeholders before implementing the National Priority Areas, introduced in 2020. FEMA's outreach did not effectively solicit stakeholder feedback, while DHS had not fully documented its rationale for changes to the priorities over several years.
GAO also identified weaknesses in the data and methods FEMA uses to determine grant eligibility and funding levels. In September 2018 and July 2023, the agency found that FEMA had not fully followed recognized scientific practices when maintaining its risk assessment model for two homeland security grants and its transit security grant model. The models did not consistently explain underlying assumptions, including how different risk factors were weighted or why calculations changed from year to year. The transit security model also excluded cyber threats, even though DHS identified them as a relevant security risk.
GAO warned that funding disruptions and a lack of transparency threaten FEMA's ability to direct limited preparedness funding toward communities where it could reduce the greatest risks.
The Bottom Line
GAO identified four open recommendations FEMA could address to improve grant administration: fully disclose the criteria used to evaluate applications, ensure evaluations align with the agency's funding priorities, account for relevant threats in certain grant risk models, and incorporate lessons from previous challenges before taking future grant actions.
Preparedness grant recipients rely on the funding to build and maintain emergency response capabilities over time, including replacing expired personal protective equipment. GAO warned that improving transparency, communication, and risk assessments is essential to ensuring federal preparedness funding reaches communities based on their security needs.
A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article