Why It Matters
The Treasury Department’s suspension of the IRS Direct File program puts a taxpayer-facing filing option at the center of a policy choice examined in the Congressional Research Service report “The IRS Direct File Program,” published Sept. 17. The program gave certain taxpayers a free, secure portal on the Internal Revenue Service website for electronically filing federal returns during the 2024 and 2025 filing seasons.
Whether the government should preserve an IRS-operated path that lowers filing barriers or rely more heavily on private providers that already participate in free tax-filing arrangements. The report says electronic filing can speed refunds, reduce IRS processing costs, lower tax evasion, and potentially increase federal revenue.
For Congress, the issue now includes legislation identified as S. 3948 and H.R. 7806, which was introduced to restore the suspended program. For taxpayers, the practical question is whether free filing remains available through a government portal, a private-company website, or both.
The Big Picture
The IRS had not offered a guided direct-filing option through a secure website portal before 2024, although taxpayers could use Free File, Volunteer Income Tax Assistance, or Free Fillable Forms.
The arrangement with commercial tax-software companies began in 2002, when the IRS agreed not to develop its own tool; that restriction was removed in 2019. The Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 provided $15 million for a feasibility task force and a report to Congress, after which the IRS tested a pilot in February 2024 and launched the option in mid-March.
The service was designed for do-it-yourself returns with guided assistance, integrated with several state filing systems, and became available in 12 states in 2024 and 25 states in 2025. Eligibility covered relatively simple tax situations and specified income types, including W-2 wages, Social Security or railroad retirement income, certain retirement income, unemployment compensation, and interest of $1,500 or less.
The 2025 version added Alaska Permanent Fund Dividends and five tax benefits, including the Child and Dependent Care Credit, the Premium Tax Credit, and a deduction for Health Savings Account contributions.
The Bottom Line
The program’s reach remained limited relative to the population the IRS estimated could use it: about 19 million taxpayers were eligible in 2024, and 32 million were eligible in 2025.
Usage was 141,000 returns in 2024 and more than 309,000 in 2025, while the latter filing season’s participation represented 1.0 Percent of eligible taxpayers. Those results fell below the IRS’s initial 2025 forecast of between 450,000 and 1.25 million returns, with the agency citing limited awareness and preferences for paid preparers or prior-year filing methods.
User surveys offered a different measure of performance, with 90% of roughly 11,000 respondents rating the 2024 experience excellent or above average and 94% of roughly 8,900 respondents doing so in 2025. Treasury reported program costs of $32 million for the 2024 filing season and $41 million for the 2025 season, excluding additional expenses incurred by other IRS offices.
The unresolved policy question is whether proposed Free File enhancements, including expanded promotion, user-experience evaluation, design improvements, and stronger oversight, can address the trade-offs Congress must weigh when considering restoration legislation.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article