Why It Matters
The RURAL Healthcare Act (H.R. 8347) is on the House Union Calendar, which makes it eligible for a floor vote. It would reclassify temporary "locum tenens" clinicians as independent contractors for federal labor law purposes, and the bill's status is listed as Floor Consideration.
Under the bill, physicians, nurse practitioners, physician assistants and certified registered nurse anesthetists would be independent contractors, not employees, if they work under a written contract at a single location for no more than one continuous year. The designation would apply under the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA) and the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). Those workers would not get the wage, overtime and collective bargaining protections those laws give employees. The bill carries no new funding.
The Big Picture
Rep. Burgess Owens (R-UT-4) introduced the bill April 16, and it went to the House Committee on Education and Workforce. The committee held a markup on July 21 and ordered the bill reported as amended on a roll call of 18-15. The reported text was filed Nov. 2 as H. Rept. 119-867, and the bill was placed on the Union Calendar as Calendar No. 764 the same day.
At the session, Owens defended the contractor designation, saying these clinicians "choose to operate as independent contractors, much like millions of other self-employed American workers." Rep. Robert C. "Bobby" Scott (D-VA-3) countered that despite the bill's title, it "will not actually improve access to health care in rural communities." He argued it lets employers misclassify health care workers and strip protections including overtime pay, unemployment and workers' compensation, and collective bargaining rights, according to the hearing transcript.
Support in the bill's cosponsor list is thin. Rep. Glenn Grothman (R-WI-6) signed on June 9 and is the only cosponsor; the bill has no Democratic cosponsors. The Congressional Research Service lists H.R. 8272 as a related bill.
Partisan Perspectives
Republicans. Owens said after the markup that he was "grateful that today the Education and Workforce Committee passed my RURAL Healthcare Act," and framed the bill as sparing rural-serving physicians and advanced practitioners "needless red tape and regulatory uncertainty," per his committee release. In his introduction release, he said the bill lets clinicians working as independent contractors "continue filling in on these critical rural shifts."
Democrats. Scott said the bill "simply allows employers to misclassify health care workers as independent contractors and effectively strip them of their rights and protections," as recorded in the transcript. House Education and Workforce Committee Democrats made a similar case in a statement, arguing the bill would take away workers' rights and reduce pay rather than address rural health care problems.
Outside the chamber, the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) covered the bill on June 15 as a debate over access and worker rights.
The Bottom Line
The bill turns on a classification question: whether short-term clinicians are employees or contractors. That determines who holds FLSA wage protections and NLRA bargaining rights. The committee split 18-15 and the cosponsor list is entirely Republican, so floor consideration would put a contested labor law change before the full House.
The latest action on the bill is the Union Calendar placement, and no floor vote date has been announced. If the House takes up Calendar No. 764, the floor vote will be the first test of the bill beyond the 18-15 committee split. The related H.R. 8272 covers the same subject.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article