Why It Matters

The Department of the Treasury has failed to consistently apply standards intended to protect American producers from foreign competition financed by international development banks, potentially harming U.S. industries, according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report published Nov. 10. ​

Between January 2015 and August 2025, Treasury cast more than 11,000 votes on projects financed by multilateral development banks, supporting 83% of the 340 projects GAO identified as likely falling under a federal law intended to protect U.S. producers from harmful foreign competition.

The findings raise concerns about whether federal officials are adequately enforcing protections for American industries when deciding which overseas development projects receive financial support.

The Big Picture

Under 22 U.S.C. § 262h, Treasury must instruct U.S. executive directors at international financial institutions to oppose assistance for projects involving commodities or minerals that are in surplus on world markets if their export would cause substantial injury to American producers of the same, similar or competing products. All three statutory conditions must be met for the requirement to apply.

Congress requested the review to determine whether Treasury was properly implementing the law, how U.S. officials voted on potentially affected projects, and whether those projects contributed to economic harm in selected domestic industries.

GAO reviewed federal laws and agency documents, analyzed international trade data and voting records, interviewed government officials, and conducted fieldwork in four states with representatives from the U.S. shrimp and rice industries. The investigation identified significant weaknesses in Treasury's procedures for evaluating whether overseas projects could harm American businesses.

Advertisement

Although Treasury has established criteria for determining whether commodities or minerals are in surplus on world markets, agency officials acknowledged that they rarely apply those criteria. GAO also found that Treasury has no established criteria for determining what constitutes "substantial injury" to U.S. producers, leaving officials to make decisions based on subjective assessments rather than consistent standards. Without clear criteria, Treasury could reach different conclusions about projects with similar circumstances, potentially allowing financing for overseas production that harms domestic industries.

The agency also found transparency problems in Treasury's voting records. Although the department publicly reports its votes on development bank projects, it does not identify which projects were evaluated under the federal statute. As a result, American producers and other stakeholders cannot readily determine whether Treasury considered the law's protections when deciding to support or oppose particular projects.

The Bottom Line

GAO issued four recommendations to Treasury aimed at strengthening its review procedures and improving transparency. Treasury concurred with all four, which remain open. Three recommendations call for developing or reviewing criteria used to identify covered commodities and minerals, determine whether they are in surplus on world markets and assess whether overseas projects could cause substantial injury to U.S. producers. The fourth calls for Treasury to identify in its public voting records when a project was considered relevant to the statute.

GAO has not identified implementation dates and said it will update the recommendations' status after confirming what actions Treasury has taken. The report also identified potential economic consequences for American shrimp producers. GAO found evidence that development bank-financed aquaculture projects in Ecuador increased shrimp imports into the United States and may have contributed to lower domestic shrimp prices, adding to financial pressures on American producers. However, the agency emphasized that foreign-financed projects were only one of several potential factors affecting the industry, alongside broader market competition, regulatory requirements, and environmental conditions.

GAO found no evidence linking development bank projects to the challenges facing American rice producers, the other industry the report examined. The Southern Shrimp Alliance, which represents domestic shrimp producers, published a statement responding to the findings, offering the industry's perspective on Treasury's enforcement of the law.

The findings highlight how federal decisions about financing overseas development can affect domestic industries and raise questions about whether existing legal protections are being applied consistently.

A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article