Why It Matters

The Department of Labor (DOL) has not issued specific guidance to help 401(k) plan sponsors and participants understand private equity investments, even as the asset class is expected to become more common in retirement plans, according to a Government Accountability Office (GAO) report released publicly Nov. 10. ​

GAO found that little is known about how much private equity 401(k) plans currently hold, and its review of selected research papers found no consensus on whether private equity outperforms publicly traded stocks. The findings raise concerns about whether retirement savers and plan administrators have enough information to evaluate the risks and potential returns of these investments.

The Big Picture

Private equity investments have historically been available primarily to wealthy individuals and institutional investors, including pension funds. However, recent industry developments and federal actions suggest that more investment products offered through 401(k) plans could soon include larger private equity allocations. Federal law authorizes DOL to issue regulations and other guidance to protect retirement security, but GAO found that the department has not provided specific guidance explaining how private equity differs from traditional retirement investments.

Private equity falls within the broad, undefined category of alternative assets and differs from publicly traded stocks in who can invest, how investments are valued and what financial disclosures are required. GAO's review of academic research found widely varying conclusions about private equity's investment performance, reflecting differences in the data, benchmarks and methodologies researchers used.

Some studies found that private equity funds outperformed publicly traded stocks during the periods examined, although the size of those gains varied significantly. Other studies found that private equity underperformed after accounting for investment risks or fees, which can be higher than those associated with publicly traded investments. One study also used benchmarks that did not include a risk premium, the additional return some experts believe private equity should provide to compensate investors for taking on greater risks.

GAO found no consensus on how to measure private equity performance against public market investments, making comparisons more difficult for retirement plan administrators and participants. To conduct the review, GAO analyzed federal and private financial data; examined research papers and investment disclosures, including Securities and Exchange Commission filings; and interviewed industry representatives, consumer advocates, and officials from the United States and four other countries.

Advertisement

Plan sponsors and industry associations told GAO that administrators need more education about how private equity investments are valued, particularly compared with traditional retirement products such as mutual funds. Consumer advocates also emphasized the need to explain illiquidity, which can make private equity investments harder to sell or convert into cash than publicly traded securities. GAO identified broader gaps in how information about private equity investments is collected and communicated to retirement plan sponsors and participants.

The Bottom Line

GAO issued three recommendations to DOL's Employee Benefits Security Administration to improve transparency and help retirement savers understand private equity investments. All three remain open.

The first recommendation calls for collecting data on the total amount of 401(k) assets invested in private equity, including investments held indirectly through underlying assets in retirement plan investment options. For large plans, GAO suggested collecting this information through existing federal reporting forms or an additional reporting section.

The second recommendation calls for guidance to plan sponsors explaining how private equity is defined, how its liquidity and valuation differ from traditional investments, and how the asset class is regulated. The third calls for guidance to retirement plan participants explaining differences in liquidity, valuation and other factors that could affect their ability to compare investment options.

According to GAO, DOL neither agreed nor disagreed with the recommendations. All three remain open, and the report establishes no implementation deadlines. GAO published the report Oct. 8 and released it publicly Nov. 10. The findings underscore the potential consequences for Americans who depend on their 401(k) accounts for retirement security. Plan sponsors have fiduciary responsibilities when selecting investment options, while participants must weigh the risks and benefits of the investments available to them.

As private equity becomes more accessible through retirement plans, GAO warned that better data and guidance could help both groups make informed decisions about investments that operate differently from traditional mutual funds. GAO said it will update the status of its recommendations after confirming what actions DOL has taken.

A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article