Why It Matters
Tribes cannot start the process of returning state criminal jurisdiction to the federal government, and states can begin it without tribal consent, a gap that impedes tribal sovereignty and self-determination, according to a U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report on Public Law 280 published Nov. 16. As of October, approximately 65 percent of the 575 federally recognized Tribes were located in states named in the law.
The Big Picture
In 1953, Public Law 280 (P.L. 280) rescinded most federal criminal jurisdiction in Indian country in select states and gave it to those states. In those states, Tribes generally share criminal jurisdiction with the state when a tribal citizen commits a crime or, in certain circumstances, is the victim of one.
Tribes and states exercise that jurisdiction in different ways. Some Tribes and local law enforcement agencies have entered cross-deputization agreements, which generally give tribal police officers the same or similar jurisdiction and related authority as local officers, within and outside Indian country. Some states have returned their P.L. 280 jurisdiction to the federal government, a step known as retrocession.
Tribal leaders say that retrocession helped their Tribes exercise self-determination and addressed some challenges working with state law enforcement. State law enforcement officials said it can be a challenge because Tribes would lose access to state public safety and justice services.
GAO's analysis of Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) data found that from fiscal years 2017 through 2021, Tribes in states named in P.L. 280 received less public safety and justice funding per capita than Tribes in all other states. BIA officials said they have limited discretionary funding and generally prioritize Tribes that do not receive such services from their states.
GAO said it was asked to review the law's effect on tribal public safety and justice, and it cited prior research suggesting the law may have adverse effects, including slow police response times and limited access to certain federal funding. It had also earlier issued a report on the law's effect in Alaska. This report covers the lower 48 states, using federal crime and funding data for fiscal years 2017 through 2024, the most recent available, and interviews with BIA and Department of Justice officials, legal scholars, other stakeholders, and tribal leaders and state law enforcement officials from three states subject to the law.
The Bottom Line
No agency received a recommendation. GAO instead presented two matters for congressional consideration, and both are listed as open, meaning actions to satisfy their intent "have not been taken or are being planned."
The first matter asks Congress to consider amending the law to authorize Tribes to initiate retrocession and to make federal criminal jurisdiction exclusive as to a state once the Secretary of the Interior accepts retrocession.
The second asks Congress to consider requiring tribal consent before a state offers retrocession to the Secretary of the Interior. Under current federal law, GAO said, absent amendments, the statute impedes Tribes' exercise of self-determination, so any change to who can start retrocession, and who must consent, rests with Congress.
Readers can follow any bill that would amend P.L. 280 on Legis1.
A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article