Why It Matters
A Supreme Court ruling on Colorado's preschool funding rules could affect how governments condition funding for religious schools, according to a new Congressional Research Service (CRS) report. The Court heard arguments on Nov. 3 in St. Mary Catholic Parish in Littleton v. Roy.
Two Catholic parishes and their preschools sought public funding through Colorado's universal preschool program but objected to signing its nondiscrimination agreement. CRS says the ruling could affect the federal government's ability to apply statutes, regulations, or contract provisions that conflict with the religious beliefs of regulated entities or beneficiaries. Programs such as the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and Head Start are among those where religious entities could seek exemptions from funding conditions.
The Big Picture
Colorado requires participating preschools to offer equal enrollment opportunities regardless of characteristics including religious affiliation, sexual orientation and gender identity. The state denied the parishes' request for a religious exemption. The trial court denied a preliminary injunction, and the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed.
The dispute turns on which Free Exercise Clause test applies. In Sherbert v. Verner, the Court required a compelling state interest to justify denying unemployment benefits because of a religious practice. Employment Division v. Smith later held that neutral, generally applicable laws can burden religious practices without triggering heightened scrutiny. The petitioners asked the Court to overrule Smith, but it declined to consider that question.
The preschools and the U.S. Solicitor General, who participated in oral arguments on their side, argued that Smith should not apply to public benefits. Chief Justice John Roberts said, "nothing in our precedent has backed away from Sherbert." Justice Elena Kagan asked whether that view was consistent with Smith, which she suggested "got rid of" the Sherbert analysis.
Colorado argued its conditions are "impartial and uniform" and that the preschools remain welcome to participate. The preschools countered that the program's income, disability, and catchall preferences create exemptions. Colorado denied that its program allows exceptions to the equal opportunity requirement.
CRS describes potential outcomes, not predictions. If Sherbert governs, strict scrutiny could apply to religious objections to funding conditions, and CRS says this "may affect the government's ability to control and oversee funds." If Smith governs, courts would still have to decide whether a condition is neutral and generally applicable, and a ruling on general applicability alone "might have less far-reaching consequences."
CRS also says the Religious Freedom Restoration Act already requires the federal government to meet strict scrutiny when its actions substantially burden religious exercise. Appellate decisions differ on what constitutes a substantial burden, so CRS says RFRA review may not match constitutional strict scrutiny.
The Bottom Line
The case has been argued but remains undecided. Whether the Court follows Sherbert or Smith could affect how federal funding conditions apply to religious organizations. Members of Congress who filed amicus briefs are on opposing sides over whether allowing states to impose nondiscrimination requirements undermines school choice or whether broad religious exemptions could undermine neutral laws.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article