Why It Matters

A bipartisan committee-approved bill would take the first step toward making the Bay Area Ridge Trail a national scenic trail, potentially giving the approximately 550-mile route around San Francisco Bay greater federal recognition. H.R. 7254 would amend the National Trails System Act to direct the Secretary of the Interior to study whether the Bay Area Ridge Trail qualifies for national scenic trail designation. The study would have to be completed within three years of enactment. ​

The legislation would not designate the trail itself. Congress would have to pass separate legislation to grant that status after the feasibility study. Rep. Jared Huffman (D-CA) sponsored the bill, which would establish the federal review process outlined in the committee-reported text.

The Big Picture

Huffman introduced the legislation Jan. 27 with 11 original cosponsors, all California Democrats, including Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) and Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-CA). The House referred the measure to the Natural Resources Subcommittee on Federal Lands on June 24, and it was among seven bills considered during a July 1 legislative hearing. The full committee subsequently ordered the bill reported as amended by unanimous consent Sept. 15.

The potential financial and management obligations associated with new federal trail designations emerged as a concern during the hearing. Rep. Emily Randall (D-WA) said a primary concern about new federal designations is "the potential long-term fiscal and management burden placed on the federal government." Randall also noted that the Trump administration's testimony opposed studying additional national trail designations because the administration was prioritizing deferred maintenance on existing federal lands.

Supporters argued that national scenic trail designation would not transfer ownership or management responsibilities to the federal government. Janet McBride, executive director of the Bay Area Ridge Trail Council, told the subcommittee the trail "is and would continue to be owned and managed by 40 different land managing partners." She added that national scenic trail status "wouldn't change any of that at all."

Rep. Mike Thompson (D-CA) described the legislation as a critical first step toward national scenic trail designation. Rep. Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA) said he joined the Bay Area congressional delegation in introducing legislation to designate the trail. Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) also backed the effort. His office announced that the Senate unanimously passed its version of the legislation.

Advertisement

The Daily Republic reported Jan. 30 on the introduction of legislation seeking national scenic trail designation, while GearJunkie described the House measure as directing a feasibility study rather than immediately designating the route.

The Bottom Line

The House Natural Resources Committee reported H.R. 7254 on Oct. 29 with H. Rept. 119-855, and the measure was placed on the Union Calendar. No House floor vote has been scheduled. The legislation would authorize a feasibility study, not establish a new national scenic trail. Any subsequent designation would require another act of Congress.

Two considerations could influence the bill's prospects. The Trump administration's stated opposition to studying additional trail designations raises questions about federal spending and management priorities. Meanwhile, all 11 original cosponsors are California Democrats, although the committee advanced the legislation by unanimous consent.

The bill record identifies the East Bay Regional Park District and lobbying firm Kountoupes Denham Carr & Reid LLC among entities associated with the legislation. Next, the bill will go to the House floor for consideration, and Schiff's office has announced passage of a companion measure in the Senate. The outcome will determine whether the Interior Department begins formally evaluating the Bay Area Ridge Trail for national scenic trail status.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article