Why It Matters
Almost all traffic engineers and other practitioners interviewed said they have never or rarely deviated from federal traffic control devices standards, even where the rules allow it, according to a U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) report on the national traffic control devices manual.
Several reported deviating occasionally to save on costs or to address local issues affecting efficiency or safety, while the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) permits deviations under certain conditions, including to protect vulnerable road users.
The Big Picture
The FHWA issues the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices for Streets and Highways to establish uniform national criteria for signs, signals, and pavement markings. The report says that uniformity promotes traffic safety and efficiency by reducing confusion for road users. Almost all practitioners GAO interviewed view the Manual as the authoritative source of standards and guidance, and many said deviations risk detracting from uniformity.
The FHWA revises the Manual and weighs practitioner feedback when it does, including change requests and successful experiments that tested new devices or applications. The 11th Edition (2023) includes new devices meant to enhance safety for vulnerable road users, such as pedestrians and cyclists.
GAO was asked to review how practitioners deviate from the Manual to protect vulnerable road users. The report says safety organizations have expressed concern that engineers may be unwilling to deviate even when doing so might make roadways safer for those users.
On information access, FHWA maintains a public online database that tracks requests for experiments, interpretations, and changes to the Manual, but the database provides few details on experiments or change requests. FHWA told GAO it has that information and provides it to practitioners on request. The option is not clearly stated on FHWA's website, and many practitioners are unaware of it.
The Bottom Line
The Department of Transportation (DOT) received one recommendation: that the Secretary of Transportation ensure the FHWA Administrator prominently displays, on the Manual's website, contact information and clear instructions on how the public may obtain more detailed information on experiments listed in the Official Rulings database. DOT agreed with it. GAO lists the recommendation as open, meaning actions to satisfy its intent have not been taken or are being planned, and says it will provide updated information when it confirms what actions the agency has taken.
Many traffic engineers told GAO they were reluctant to deviate from the Manual's requirements because of the possibility of facing a lawsuit if a crash were to occur at the site of the deviation. The report says clearer access to experiment details could help practitioners prepare their own requests and test devices on the roads they operate, which GAO says would promote the Manual's objectives of safety and efficiency.
A linked invitation to track related legislative activity on Legis1
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article