Why it Matters

House Republicans examined whether union leaders represent workers or push political agendas on September 15. The hearing, titled "Out Of Touch: When Union Politics Leave Workers Behind," exposed sharp disagreements over how union dues are spent. The Trump administration backs transparency measures that constrain union power, a stance aligned with this investigation.

The Big Picture

The hearing reflected months of Republican pressure on labor unions. In August, the House Committee on Education and Workforce demanded financial records from five major unions, seeking details on political spending and lavish perks. In June, the Department of Labor finalized an overhaul of union financial reporting requirements, with enhanced disclosures effective July 1.

The Trump administration has moved aggressively against unions since January 2025. On April 9, Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth issued a memo directing management to terminate collective bargaining agreements to comply with Trump's Executive Order 14821. The 9th Circuit upheld Trump's 2025 executive order eliminating collective bargaining rights for wide swaths of government workers, citing national security grounds.

According to Ranking Member Rep. Mark DeSaulnier (D-CA-10), since Citizens United in 2010, corporations have spent nearly $1.7 billion on federal elections, with $646 million in the current cycle alone.

What They're Saying

Four witnesses testified, with three from conservative organizations, plus one academic.

Greg Mourad of the National Right to Work Committee argued that "union leaders like spending other people's money on their own political agenda." He called for freeing workers from forced unionism nationwide.

Thomas S. Jones of the American Accountability Foundation presented data claiming workers split 50-50 politically, yet unions spend more than 90 percent of political funds on Democrats.

Adam Dean testified as a witness from The George Washington University. Akash Chougule of the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity emphasized that workers cannot easily remove or change unions.

Rep. DeSaulnier noted union approval stands at 71 percent according to Gallup, despite just 10 percent of workers belonging to unions. He highlighted wage stagnation, specifically that from 1979 to 2023, bottom 90 percent wages rose 40 percent while top 1 percent income jumped more than 180 percent.

Political Stakes

The hearing puts unions in a bind. With Republican control of the House and Senate, labor faces sustained investigation and potential legislation restricting dues collection. Rep. Bob Onder (R-MO-3) introduced the Improving Clarity and Transparency for Unions Act in July, designed to hold union leaders accountable.

The AFL-CIO filed suit against the DOL on June 10, challenging the final disclosure rule, arguing that certain disclosure requirements may exceed the authority granted to the DOL under the LMRDA.

Yet public support for unions remains strong, complicating the GOP's messaging.

Yes, But

The witness list drew criticism. The hearing's witness list was drawn entirely from conservative organizations (American Accountability Foundation, Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, National Right to Work Committee) plus one academic. Democrats received only one witness against Republicans' three. No union leaders testified to defend themselves.

The Guardian reported on September 1 that House Republicans are investigating several US labor unions based on claims from far-right nonprofits alleging union dues are being used for illegal political funding.

What's Next

H.R. 9636 has been referred to the House Committee on Education and Workforce. The AFL-CIO filed suit against the DOL in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on June 10, challenging the final disclosure rule. The Department of Labor's enhanced reporting requirements take effect July 1.

The Bottom Line

On August 6, House Committee Chairman Tim Walberg (R-MI) and Subcommittee Chairman Rick Allen (R-GA) demanded records of political expenditures, PAC contributions, and lobbying disbursements from the United Auto Workers, United Steelworkers, and three rail unions. Rep. Onder introduced H.R. 9636, the Improving Clarity and Transparency for Unions Act of 2026, on July 9, while the Department of Labor finalized a major overhaul of union financial reporting requirements, effective July 1.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article