Why It Matters
A federal district court has ruled that the National Firearms Act's registration requirements for firearms with no remaining tax exceed Congress's constitutional powers, according to a new Congressional Research Service (CRS) report.
The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) acted under the Trump administration. Its director issued an open letter stating that, effective Oct. 9, ATF will no longer require approval before individuals make or transfer short-barreled rifles, short-barreled shotguns, silencers and "any other weapon[s]." ATF will also no longer require those items to be registered in the National Firearms Registration and Transfer Record.
The Big Picture
The dispute traces to P.L. 119-21, commonly known as the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act." The law set a $0 tax rate, effective Jan. 1, for making or transferring National Firearms Act firearms that are not machineguns or destructive devices. It became law on July 4, 2025.
CRS says the law did not repeal the National Firearms Act or its regulations. The special occupational tax, the approval requirements, the background checks, the registration and the criminal penalties for possessing an unregistered firearm all remain in place.
In Silencer Shop Foundation v. ATF, the plaintiffs, "a coalition of individuals, businesses, associations, and states," argued that Congress relied on its taxing power to enact the registration rules. They contended that with the tax eliminated, that power can no longer support the rules for silencers, short-barreled rifles, short-barreled shotguns and "any other weapon."
On Aug. 5, the federal district court sitting in the Northern District of Texas agreed with the facial challenge. It reasoned that "without a tax that raises at least some revenue, Congress cannot enact a statute under its taxing power."
The court also rejected the other constitutional bases examined. It found the Necessary and Proper Clause cannot stand alone as a source of authority, and it concluded the Commerce Clause was not the basis Congress relied on. It declined to address the plaintiffs' Second Amendment claim.
ATF's guidance page says the court's injunction covers the plaintiffs and other specified persons. It describes the broader nonenforcement policy as an exercise of enforcement discretion. The page says the National Firearms Act remains in full effect for machineguns and destructive devices.
The Bottom Line
Invalidating these provisions would likely leave the affected firearms regulated like other firearms under the Gun Control Act, without the tracking, registration and associated penalties. Congress could add a dollar amount to the tax, identify a separate constitutional basis such as interstate commerce, or remove the registration requirements or the funding to enforce them.
Congress's ability to address the Second Amendment question is unclear, because the court did not reach that claim.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article