Why it Matters

The House Subcommittee on Government Operations convened a Postal Regulatory Commission (PRC) hearing on Thursday, June 4 that put the agency's four commissioners before Congress to confront a stark reality: the U.S. Postal Service is burning cash, its flagship reform plan has failed, and the Trump administration is eyeing a restructuring that would upend decades of independent oversight. Tensions surfaced immediately as commissioners rejected USPS management’s preferred fix, dismissing the Postmaster General’s request for more borrowing authority as “more money with less oversight.”

The Big Picture

This was the fourth in a series of subcommittee hearings on USPS's financial deterioration, following a March appearance by Postmaster General David Steiner in which he warned the agency would run out of cash within 12 months. In April, the PRC issued an emergency waiver of minimum retirement payment requirements, providing up to $15 billion in relief through 2030, buying Congress some breathing room. But commissioners made clear that relief is temporary.

The Delivering for America plan, launched under former Postmaster General Louis DeJoy, promised break-even operations by 2023. Instead, USPS has posted $31 billion in losses over the plan's first six years. Congress passed the Postal Service Reform Act of 2022, which provided roughly $57 billion in balance sheet relief and enrolled retirees in Medicare. It wasn't enough. Meanwhile, the Trump administration has floated moving USPS under the Commerce Department, a proposal that would directly threaten the PRC's independence.

What They're Saying:

Rep. Pete Sessions (R-TX), the subcommittee chair, pressed commissioners on whether USPS's proposed $15 billion borrowing cap increase would actually solve the crisis. Taub, acting as agency head due to a vacant chairmanship, was direct: it would extend the timeline before insolvency, but not prevent it.

Rep. Kweisi Mfume (D-MD),used his closing time to raise a question that hung over the hearing: the Trump administration's reported interest in placing USPS under the Commerce Department. Taub said he was unaware of active efforts in that direction, but didn't dismiss the concern. Mfume called the $15 billion borrowing request "poppycock" as a standalone fix, aligning with the commissioners' cautionary posture.

Ann Fisher, Commissioner, Postal Regulatory Commission, offered a frank assessment of the rate system's limits. She noted that labor comprises roughly 70% of postal costs, and that despite a 45% rate increase since 2021, well above the 23% inflation authority the PRC granted, losses have only grown. "The current trajectory is not self-correcting," she said.

Thomas Day, Commissioner, Postal Regulatory Commission, drew on his 35 years inside USPS management to deliver the most operationally specific critique. He called the Delivering for America plan "fundamentally flawed," citing its use of a uniform 50-mile radius for regional processing centers regardless of geography. His example: the Miami facility's 50-mile radius extends into the Atlantic Ocean to the east and the Everglades to the west. "No two places are the same," he said, arguing USPS should redesign its network using existing infrastructure rather than press forward with a broken model.

Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC) pressed Taub on whether USPS is duplicating private-sector technology investments, calling the agency a "bloated federal jobs program." Taub acknowledged the PRC lacks direct authority to police those decisions but said the commission has authority to hear complaints when USPS uses its regulatory position to unfairly compete with private companies.

Rep. Maxwell Frost (D-FL) raised the regional transportation optimization plan, which could affect 72% of post offices, and asked whether the PRC believes it will achieve projected savings. Poling said the commission's January 2025 advisory opinion found the plan would disproportionately harm rural America. "It brings none of us any joy that some of our findings were right," she said.

Political Stakes

The hearing carries real stakes for the PRC itself. Former Postmaster General DeJoy publicly called the commission "an unnecessary agency." Steiner has urged Congress to give USPS more pricing freedom with fewer regulatory constraints. If Congress moves toward that view, the PRC's institutional role could be substantially diminished or eliminated in any reform legislation. The commissioners appeared aware of this dynamic, with Taub noting that Congress created the PRC precisely because it didn't trust USPS to set its own rates without oversight.

For the administration, the hearing exposed a tension between its stated interest in fiscal discipline and the political cost of degraded service in rural areas, a core Republican constituency. First-class stamp prices are set to rise to 82 cents next month, a 49% increase in five years. Commissioners noted that USPS has used every available rate authority, and then some, while service has gotten worse.

Rep. Emily Randall (D-WA) raised election mail directly, noting that Washington is a universal vote-by-mail state and that service delays raise questions about ballot reliability. Poling said election mail has historically performed better than standard mail due to the extraordinary measures USPS takes during election periods, but acknowledged the broader service degradation is a real concern.

Rep. Brandon Gill (R-TX) walked through the financial math methodically: USPS lost $9 billion in fiscal year 2025 and roughly $31 billion since launching the Delivering for America plan. Employee count fell from roughly 671,000 in 2010 to 624,000 in 2025, while mail volume dropped 36% over the same period. The imbalance, Taub confirmed, is a core driver of the financial collapse.

Yes, but:

Day acknowledged that under the current Postmaster General Steiner, "real results are being achieved" on service improvement and cost reduction. The problem, he argued, is structural: even good management can't fully overcome a fundamentally flawed network design. Fisher similarly noted that the PRC's 2020 ratemaking reform gave USPS tools that helped stabilize revenue, even if they couldn't overcome the underlying structural deficit.

What's Next

The PRC opened a public inquiry into its methodology for valuing the universal service obligation (USO) the day after the hearing, on June 5. That proceeding could inform future ratemaking and any legislative effort to codify the USO. Proposed USPS rate changes averaging 4.8% are set to take effect July 12, landing before the November 2026 midterms. Sessions indicated he and Mfume plan to visit the St. Louis postal hub, which has been the subject of documented service failures, as part of ongoing oversight.

The Bottom Line

The PRC commissioners arrived in agreement with the Postmaster General on one thing, that Congress must define what it wants from the Postal Service and fund it, but they delivered a pointed warning that more borrowing without that definition will only delay, not prevent, a reckoning.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.