Why It Matters
The Valuing Employee Stock Today Act (H.R. 8660) now sits on the House Union Calendar, which makes the bill eligible for floor consideration and a VEST Act vote possible. The bill would add restricted stock units (RSUs) to the list of equity pay that employers can leave out of the "regular rate" used to calculate overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938.
Restricted stock units are a form of employee compensation where an employer promises to deliver shares of company stock, or their cash equivalent, after meeting specific conditions. For employers with hourly or salaried staff who receive RSUs, the question is whether the stock's value raises the overtime owed.
The reported text says the amendments would take effect 90 days after enactment, according to the bill summary. Employers would be shielded from liability for not counting RSU income before that date, during a 12-month transition for existing programs that need shareholder approval to change, and for RSU programs covered by current collective bargaining agreements.
The Big Picture
Rep. Ryan Mackenzie (R-PA-7) introduced the bill May 4 and it was referred to the Education and Workforce Committee, chaired by Rep. Tim Walberg (R-MI-5). At a July 21 markup, the committee ordered it reported as amended by a recorded vote of 18-15. It was reported Nov. 2 as H. Rept. 119-868 and placed on the Union Calendar as Calendar No. 765. Rep. Bob Onder (R-MO-3) is the lone cosponsor, added July 21.
The bill's supporters argue that current law already excludes stock options, stock appreciation rights and employee stock purchase programs from the regular rate, and that RSUs, which have become widespread since that exclusion was written in 2000, should be treated the same. The National Center for Employee Ownership wrote May 27 that the change would make the law more consistent and could encourage companies to offer RSUs to nonexempt employees.
The tradeoff is that leaving RSU value out of the calculation can mean a lower overtime rate than counting it would produce. The minority views in the committee report characterize the bill as allowing employers to pay workers less overtime than they are owed. The committee vote of 18-15 shows the disagreement carried through markup.
Partisan Perspectives
At the markup, Rep. Burgess Owens (R-UT-4) argued that employer-provided stock options, stock appreciation rights and employee stock purchase programs are already excluded from the regular rate. He said RSUs should get the same treatment so hourly nonexempt employees can receive the same equity compensation as exempt employees.
Rep. Robert C. "Bobby" Scott (D-VA-3), the ranking Democrat, opposed the bill. He said "RSUs are different from the other programs," because employees do not purchase them or pay a price when they vest. He said any exemption from the regular rate "chips away at the distance that makes a 40-hour work week the rule rather than the exception."
The Bottom Line
The bill is a narrow change to overtime math, and it divides on employer flexibility versus overtime pay. It has cleared committee and is eligible for floor consideration, but no floor vote has been held.
Obstacles are visible in the numbers: an 18-15 committee vote, written minority views, and a single cosponsor, who is a Republican. Anyone tracking the bill should watch the House floor schedule and any Rules Committee action. If the House passes it, the measure would still need Senate action before the 90-day clock to take effect could start.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article