Why it Matters
The House Rules Committee split over H.R. 1013 at its Nov. 9 hearing, with Democrats arguing the bill would weaken protections for 403(b) plan participants. Rep. Warren Davidson (R-OH-8), the hearing's only listed witness, told the panel the bill gives those workers the same options 401(k) participants have.
Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA-43), ranking member of the House Financial Services Committee, called the bill a giveaway to banks, insurers and Wall Street firms. The committee did not agree to the amendments before it, on a vote of two yes and six no.
The Big Picture
Davidson told the committee that about 15 million 403(b) participants at hospitals, churches, charities and public schools cannot invest in collective investment trusts (CITs), which private-sector 401(k) plans can use. He said the bill was folded into the INVEST Act, which passed the House 302 to 123.
Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC-5) , the committee chair, said the H.R. 1013 bill passed the House Financial Services Committee 43 to 8.
The House Rules Committee's bill page describes a proposed Waters amendment that would require CIT trustees to give 403(b) plans a "fund fact sheet" on the product.
What They're Saying
The dispute centers on whether the bill gives 403(b) plans parity with 401(k) plans or removes protections. Waters said, "Republicans call this parity with 401k plan. It is not." She argued that the bill would let banks and insurers sell CITs without Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) registration.
Rep. Jim McGovern (D-MA-2), the ranking member, answered the parity claim by noting that the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) covers 401(k) plans. "401ks are protected by ERISA. Most 403Ks are not," he said. Davidson responded to McGovern's questions about amendments by saying Republicans had not allowed a floor amendment vote in 110 days.
Rep. Mary Gay Scanlon (D-PA-5) said her first retirement plan was a 403(b) and that she had been told it was "just like a 401k." Rep. Virginia Foxx (R-NC-5) cited opposition letters from the National Education Association (NEA), the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) and other groups, and said she needed to look at the bill further.
Political Stakes
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce urged the House to pass the bill and "encourage timely Senate consideration." The Investment Company Institute applauded House passage. NEA said the bill "threatens the retirement security of educators and other participants in 403(b) plans not covered by ERISA."
The positions track the hearing's split. Supporters emphasize access and parity, while opponents focus on participants whose plans fall outside ERISA coverage.
The Bottom Line
The House passed H.R. 1013 on Nov. 11 by 295 to 128. The Senate received the bill and referred it to the Senate Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee on Nov. 12, according to the bill's congressional actions. Senate Banking action on the bill remains pending, making that committee the next decision point for anyone tracking the bill.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article