Why it matters

The House passed legislation Nov. 11 that would expand retirement investment options for millions of public school employees, nonprofit workers, and other Americans, despite opposition from most Democrats over concerns about inadequate investor protections. ​

The Retirement Fairness for Charities and Educational Institutions Act, introduced by Rep. Frank Lucas (R-OK), passed 295-128, with unanimous support from voting Republicans and 83 Democrats. The legislation now heads to the Senate.

The bill would allow certain 403(b) retirement plans, commonly offered to public school teachers, nonprofit employees and church workers, to invest in collective investment trusts and insurance company separate accounts. These investment vehicles are already available to many private-sector employees through their 401(k) plans.

Supporters argue the change would give nonprofit and public-sector workers access to more affordable investment options, while opponents warn the legislation could expose retirement savings to financial products with insufficient federal oversight.

The Big Picture

The House Financial Services Committee advanced the legislation in a 43-8 vote on May 20, 2025, before formally reporting an amended version on Nov. 28, 2025. During a Nov. 9 House Rules Committee meeting, Rep. Warren Davidson (R-OH) argued that approximately 15 million workers at hospitals, churches, charities and public schools lack access to the same investment vehicles available through many private-sector retirement plans, according to the hearing record.

Republicans framed the proposal as a way to eliminate disparities between retirement plans offered by nonprofit employers and private businesses. Democrats raised concerns about the risks of allowing additional investment products into retirement plans that may not offer the same federal protections as traditional 401(k) plans.

Advertisement

Davidson disputed claims that the bill would open retirement accounts to "unregulated products," arguing that federal securities regulators would retain their existing authority.

Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA), the ranking member of the Financial Services Committee, offered an amendment that would have added disclosure requirements, but it was rejected.

Lucas also pointed to the House's previous approval of the legislation as part of the INVEST Act in December, saying the broader package received support from more than 300 lawmakers.

Partisan Perspectives

Republicans unanimously supported the legislation among those voting, with all 211 voting in favor and seven absent. Lucas urged the Senate to act quickly, saying, "I urge the Senate to swiftly take up and pass this bill."

Sen. Katie Britt (R-AL) welcomed the House vote and the Trump administration's support, writing, "I'm also pleased to see the White House support this commonsense bill." Davidson argued that the legislation "is trying to bring parity" between retirement plans available to nonprofit workers and those offered by private employers.

Democrats were more divided, with 83 supporting the legislation and 128 opposing it. One independent also voted in favor.

Rep. Jim McGovern (D-MA) warned that many 403(b) retirement plans lack protections available to workers enrolled in 401(k) plans, raising questions about whether expanding investment options could expose employees to unnecessary financial risk. Democrats supporting the legislation included Reps. Nikki Budzinski (D-IL), Jimmy Panetta (D-CA) and Brittany Pettersen (D-CO). Panetta and Pettersen also co-sponsored the bill.

Political Stakes

The legislation now faces an uncertain future in the Senate, where it was referred to the Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs Committee on Nov. 12. A companion bill, S. 424, was previously introduced and referred to the same committee, giving supporters another potential avenue to advance the proposal.

Supporters argue that expanding investment options could help nonprofit employers offer more competitive retirement benefits and potentially reduce investment costs. Opponents contend that Congress should strengthen oversight of 403(b) plans before allowing them to invest in additional financial products.

The Bottom Line

The bill would expand the investment options available to certain 403(b) retirement plans, potentially giving millions of public-sector and nonprofit employees access to financial products already used in private-sector retirement accounts. But the proposal remains dependent on Senate approval and the president's signature. Until then, existing restrictions on collective investment trusts and insurance company separate accounts will remain in place.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article