Why It Matters
A federal judge has ruled that Congress exceeded its constitutional authority by criminalizing noncitizen voting in federal elections, raising questions about the Trump administration's ability to prosecute such cases under federal law. The decision, detailed in a new Congressional Research Service (CRS) report, applies only to the defendant in the case but could have broader implications if upheld on appeal.
The government has appealed the ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit, where the case remains pending. The decision raises questions about Congress' authority to criminalize noncitizen voting in federal elections, although it does not invalidate the law nationwide or affect state voter eligibility requirements.
The ruling comes as the Trump administration's Department of Justice (DOJ) continues prosecuting alleged noncitizen voting. On Nov. 2, the department announced charges involving 63 individuals across multiple states for election-related offenses, including alleged violations of 18 U.S.C. § 611, which prohibits noncitizens from voting in elections for specified federal offices.
The Big Picture
On Oct. 1, a judge in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida ruled in United States v. Cox that the Constitution does not authorize Congress to enact Section 611. CRS describes the decision as addressing a question of nationwide first impression. Congress enacted the statute in 1996.
The court concluded that states possess the constitutional authority to establish voter qualifications, including citizenship requirements. It found that Oregon v. Mitchell did not control the question because the Supreme Court justices agreed on the outcome without reaching a majority rationale on the constitutional issue. The court also relied on language in Arizona v. Inter Tribal Council of Arizona distinguishing Congress' authority to regulate how federal elections are conducted from the states' authority to determine who is eligible to vote.
The court rejected two additional constitutional justifications for Section 611. It found that Congress' immigration authority did not support the prohibition, citing in part the statute's exemption for certain nonfederal elections. It also concluded that the Elections Clause concerns election procedures rather than voter qualifications and found insufficient evidence that Congress enacted the provision to prevent election fraud.
According to CRS, Cox involved an as-applied constitutional challenge resolved through a motion to dismiss. The ruling applies to the defendant's prosecution rather than invalidating Section 611 in every circumstance. The court did not address whether the federal government could remove a noncitizen for engaging in the same conduct under immigration law. It also suggested that a federal statute criminalizing voting in violation of state voter qualification laws would raise "very different" constitutional considerations.
Other federal courts have reached conflicting conclusions. A magistrate judge in the Western District of Wisconsin adopted similar reasoning to dismiss two criminal cases, which were later challenged before the district court. Meanwhile, a judge in the Northern District of Texas summarily rejected reliance on Cox in a comparable constitutional challenge raised shortly before trial. The dispute has also surfaced in litigation involving California's election administration. DOJ cited Section 611 in an Oct. 15 complaint against California concerning ballots sent to individuals the government believed were likely noncitizens.
The district court denied the administration's request for a temporary restraining order, and a divided Ninth Circuit panel upheld that denial. The Supreme Court subsequently denied an emergency injunction application without any noted dissent. DOJ voluntarily dismissed the case Nov. 6.
The Bottom Line
The 11th Circuit's review of United States v. Cox could determine whether the district court's constitutional reasoning extends beyond the individual defendant. If the appeals court upholds the ruling, similarly situated noncitizens prosecuted under Section 611 within the circuit could invoke that precedent in challenging federal charges.
Conflicting appellate decisions could eventually bring the constitutional question before the Supreme Court. Congress could also respond legislatively. Lawmakers could retain the existing statute while awaiting further judicial review, repeal it in favor of state enforcement of voter qualification laws, or amend it to criminalize voting in federal elections in violation of applicable state eligibility requirements.
For now, Section 611 remains federal law, and the Florida ruling does not establish a nationwide prohibition on its enforcement.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article