Why It Matters
A proposal to transfer nearly nine acres of Black Hills National Forest land to Pennington County, South Dakota, for a public works facility has advanced toward a Senate vote. The Senate bill, S. 5359, cleared the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee on Nov. 12 and was placed on the Senate Legislative Calendar as Calendar No. 711. No floor vote has been scheduled.
The Pennington County Land Conveyance Act would direct the Secretary of Agriculture to transfer approximately 8.97 acres of National Forest System land to the county at no cost. The proposed site is identified on a map prepared for a county highway maintenance facility, although the introduced legislation also permits other uses the county determines are necessary. After the transfer, the Forest Service would adjust the Black Hills National Forest boundary to exclude the parcel.
The proposal also raises questions about the conditions attached to transferring federal land into county ownership. The bill's summary describes a reversion provision allowing the federal government to reclaim the property if the county uses it for unauthorized purposes, subject to notice, a hearing opportunity and a chance to correct the violation. The legislation concerns a single parcel and does not establish a broader land disposal program.
The Big Picture
Sen. John Thune (R-SD) introduced the legislation Aug. 7, with Sen. Mike Rounds (R-SD) as its original and only cosponsor. Both senators represent the state where the land is located, and the bill has no Democratic or independent cosponsors.
The Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee considered the legislation during a Sept. 16 hearing. The committee ordered the bill reported favorably with an amendment in the nature of a substitute Sept. 30. Committee Chairman Mike Lee (R-UT) formally reported the amended legislation Nov. 12 without a written report, and it was placed on the Senate Legislative Calendar under General Orders as Calendar No. 711.
The reported version incorporates the committee's substitute amendment, making it important to distinguish that version from the introduced text. The original legislation identifies the 8.97-acre parcel, requires a no-cost conveyance and directs the Forest Service to modify the forest boundary. The precise conditions in the reported substitute, including any restrictions on future land use or federal reversion rights, are particularly relevant to the county and federal land managers.
The Sept. 16 hearing also examined other legislation, including S. 5352 and S. 5360. Senators questioned administration witnesses about several federal land and energy issues, including Yosemite National Park land and appliance efficiency standards. A House companion, H.R. 10190, was introduced Aug. 31 by Rep. Dusty Johnson (R-SD) and referred to the House Natural Resources Committee. It proposes transferring the same 8.97-acre parcel to Pennington County.
The Bottom Line
The legislation would transfer a specific parcel of federal forestland to Pennington County without requiring payment, potentially providing a site for county highway maintenance or other public works operations. The Forest Service would also have to revise the Black Hills National Forest boundary to reflect the conveyance.
S. 5359 has cleared committee but remains on the Senate calendar awaiting floor consideration. Its sponsors are both South Dakota Republicans, and no Democrats have joined as cosponsors. The bill would still need approval from both chambers before reaching the president.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article