Why It Matters

Senate Republicans introduced legislation this month that would establish nationwide photo identification requirements for voting in federal elections. S. 5271 would amend the Help America Vote Act of 2002 to generally prohibit election officials from providing an in-person federal ballot to a voter who does not present valid physical photo identification.

Voters without qualifying identification would be permitted to cast provisional ballots, but election officials generally could not determine them eligible unless they presented valid photo identification within three days or submitted an affidavit stating that they lack photo identification because of a religious objection to being photographed.

The proposal would significantly expand existing federal identification requirements. The Help America Vote Act currently imposes identification requirements on certain first-time voters who registered by mail, while states otherwise maintain varying voter identification rules.

The Big Picture

Sen. Jon Husted (R-OH) introduced S. 5271 on Aug. 5. Sens. Ashley Moody (R-FL) and Dan Sullivan (R-AK) subsequently joined as cosponsors. The measure was read a second time and placed on the Senate Legislative Calendar on Aug. 6.

A cloture vote on the motion to proceed failed 52-46 on Aug. 8, falling short of the three-fifths threshold required to invoke cloture. All 52 senators voting in favor were Republicans. Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and Sen. Peter Welch (D-VT) did not vote.

Senate Republicans hoped to use Democrats' likely rejection of S.5271 as a political liability, framing opponents as enablers of voter fraud heading into the November elections. Republicans had used a similar strategy earlier in the year during debate over the SAVE America Act, seeking to put Democrats on record against federal voter identification requirements.

The Brennan Center for Justice has found that voter fraud is exceedingly rare, with its review of extensively studied elections finding voter impersonation fraud rates between 0.0003 percent and 0.0025 percent.

Husted is seeking election to a full Senate term after being appointed to replace Vice President JD Vance. The Ohio race is competitive, with recent public polling showing former Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-OH) leading Husted in multiple August surveys.

Democrats attacked the measure as voter suppression. Sen. Alex Padilla (D-CA), ranking member of the Senate Rules and Administration Committee, stated that Trump and Senate Republicans prioritize a voter suppression bill while families face skyrocketing costs. Voting rights advocates have argued that strict photo identification laws can create additional barriers for eligible voters who lack qualifying identification.

The original Help America Vote Act of 2002 imposed federal identification requirements on certain first-time voters who registered by mail and had not previously voted in a federal election. S. 5271 would expand federal requirements to voters generally in elections for federal office.

Partisan Perspectives

Sen. John Hoeven (R-ND) stated that North Dakota has successfully implemented a voter ID law that ensures only eligible voters cast ballots while making it easy for those voters to participate in elections. Republicans argue that photo identification requirements help ensure that ballots are cast by eligible voters and increase confidence in elections. Opponents argue that strict photo identification requirements disproportionately burden voters who have more difficulty obtaining qualifying identification and could create additional administrative burdens shortly before the November elections.

The Bottom Line

Under S. 5271, valid photo identification for in-person voting would include a valid state driver's license with a photo and expiration date, a state-issued photo identification card with an expiration date, a U.S. passport, military identification, or a tribal government identification document containing a photo and expiration date. Military identification would include photo identification issued by the Department of Defense or Department of Veterans Affairs.

For voters casting ballots other than in person, election officials generally could not accept a ballot unless the voter submitted a copy of valid photo identification or provided the last four digits of a Social Security number along with an affidavit stating that the voter was unable to obtain a copy of qualifying identification despite reasonable efforts.

That requirement would not apply to absent uniformed services voters covered by the Uniformed and Overseas Citizens Absentee Voting Act or certain elderly and disabled voters entitled under federal law to vote through alternative methods.

States would also be required, to the extent practicable, to provide free public access to printers, copiers, scanners, or other digital imaging devices at government buildings, including courts, libraries, and police stations, so voters could make copies of their identification. States would have to notify applicants about the identification requirement when they register to vote, including through online registration systems.

The legislation would take effect one day after enactment and apply to federal elections held on or after that date. That provision could require states to make significant procedural changes on a compressed timeline if Congress enacted the bill shortly before an election. For now, the bill remains stalled in the Senate after the Aug. 8 cloture vote failed 52-46.

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article