Why It Matters
A Republican-backed bill that would restrict the Bureau of Land Management's ability to close historic roads and implement vehicle travel plans across millions of acres of Utah public land has advanced toward a Senate vote. Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT) reported the Historic Roadways Protection Act (S. 90) on Nov. 12 with an amendment in the nature of a substitute. It now sits on the Senate Legislative Calendar under General Orders as Calendar No. 696, although no floor vote has been scheduled.
As introduced, the bill would:
- Prohibit BLM from closing historical roads on public lands in certain Utah areas until the U.S. District Court for the District of Utah decides each relevant R.S. 2477 case. R.S. 2477, a provision of the Mining Law of 1866, granted rights-of-way across certain public lands.
- Prohibit the use of federal funds to finalize or implement new travel management plans for certain Utah travel management areas until the Secretary of the Interior certifies that the cases have been decided.
- Prohibit federal funding to implement the Indian Creek (Canyon Rims), San Rafael Desert, San Rafael Swell and Labyrinth/Gemini Bridges travel management plans in Utah.
Those provisions reflect the introduced legislation. The committee-reported version includes a substitute amendment, which could change the scope of the restrictions.
The Big Picture
The dispute centers on R.S. 2477, a federal law enacted in 1866 that granted rights-of-way for highways across certain public lands. Congress repealed the provision in 1976 through the Federal Land Policy and Management Act (FLPMA), but preserved valid rights-of-way established before its repeal. Utah and 22 counties subsequently filed lawsuits seeking recognition of claimed historic roads after BLM adopted travel management plans restricting vehicle access to some routes.
The Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee's Public Lands, Forests, and Mining Subcommittee examined the legislation during a Dec. 2 hearing, published as S. Hrg. 119-237. The full committee advanced the bill with a substitute amendment on Feb. 4, voting 11-9 along party lines. Sen. John Curtis (R-UT) is the legislation's only cosponsor, having joined when Lee introduced it Jan. 14, 2025. The House companion, H.R. 376, contains identical introduced legislation.
The disagreement centers on whether the proposed restrictions would protect established public access or undermine federal land management. Utah officials and counties argue their lawsuits seek recognition of existing rights-of-way rather than the creation of new roads. Conservation organizations dispute the scope of some historic road claims and warn that restricting BLM's authority could expose sensitive landscapes to additional motorized vehicle use.
Partisan Perspectives
The BlueRibbon Coalition celebrated the committee's approval as a "major victory" for public land access advocates. The organization supports protecting historic routes while courts determine whether the disputed rights-of-way are legally valid.
The Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, led by Lee, said the legislation would preserve longstanding rights-of-way across Utah public lands while litigation determines their legal status.
The Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance strongly opposes the legislation, arguing it would effectively prevent BLM from managing motorized vehicle use across more than 6 million acres of Utah's redrock country. The conservation organization warned that the restrictions could leave sensitive public lands vulnerable to environmental damage and degradation.
The Bottom Line
The Historic Roadways Protection Act would use restrictions on federal spending to prevent BLM from implementing certain travel management decisions while courts resolve disputed historic road claims. Supporters argue the measure would protect public access, while opponents warn it could substantially weaken federal oversight of vehicle use across millions of acres.
The bill cleared the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee on an 11-9 party-line vote and was reported with a substitute amendment Nov. 12. It is eligible for Senate floor consideration, but no vote is scheduled.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article