Why it matters
The House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform reported H.R. 8801 on Nov. 17, and the bill now sits on the Union Calendar, which makes it eligible for a House floor vote. The reported text would bar the District of Columbia from creating or enforcing any congestion toll and would add such tolls to the actions the DC Home Rule Act bars the DC Council from enacting. For lobbyists and staff tracking local transportation policy, that is a permanent federal prohibition, effective once enacted, on a pricing tool the District could otherwise use, with no new federal funding and no implementation timeline.
The big picture
Rep. Scott Perry (R-PA-10) introduced the bill May 13, and it was referred to the committee. On May 20, the committee took it up at a full committee markup listed under the name "DC Rejecting Oppressive Automotive Driving Surcharges Act" in the markup transcript. Members ordered the bill reported, as amended, by a 22-18 vote after a recorded vote was requested.
The dispute centers on home rule. Supporters pointed to a $10 entry fee proposed in a 2019 District study, while opponents said no congestion charge exists in the District and none is pending. Rep. Scott Perry said he introduced the bill in response to council rhetoric about congestion tolls.
The debate predates the markup. In March, the District released a decongestion-pricing study, and then Mayor Muriel Bowser criticized its analysis for relying on pre-pandemic data and containing methodological flaws. On May 25, WJLA reported that a House panel advanced the bill, describing it as a measure to block the District from implementing congestion pricing.
Partisan Perspectives
Opponents include former Rep. Eleanor Holmes Norton, who called the bill an "anti-home rule" measure in a statement ahead of the markup. At the markup, Norton called the bill "undemocratic and paternalistic." The committee's ranking member said, "DC doesn't have congestion pricing," according to the markup transcript.
Rep. Scott Perry, the bill's sponsor, defended the measure in the same transcript, calling a congestion toll "an unconstitutional tax."
The Bottom Line
The bill would settle a local pricing question through federal law, which is the source of the home-rule objection. Its path is early. The bill lists no cosponsors, its latest action is placement on the Union Calendar, and enactment would require House passage and Senate action. The American Public Transportation Association is linked to the bill as an organization and in lobbying listings.
Norton described the markup as "the fifth this congress" on District traffic policy. No floor vote date has been set. The committee's report is H. Rept. 119-884, and the reported text is the version that would reach the floor.
Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights.
Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article