Why It Matters

A federal appeals court has ruled that school districts can challenge a Title IX funding decision in district court, at least in part. ​

The Fourth Circuit's decision in Fairfax County School Board v. McMahon is analyzed in a new Congressional Research Service (CRS) report. The court vacated and remanded the dismissal of two Virginia school districts' claims after the Department of Education placed them on "high-risk" status. That status puts them on a reimbursement method of payment for certain grants.

The forum determines the relief available. The Court of Federal Claims can award money but lacks general equitable powers to issue injunctions, while a district court reviewing Administrative Procedure Act (APA) claims can grant them.

The Big Picture

The dispute began when the department's Office for Civil Rights found that the districts' policies on transgender students' access to restrooms and locker rooms violated Title IX. The districts refused a resolution agreement, and the department then designated them high-risk. They sued under the APA, arguing that the Fourth Circuit's decision in Grimm v. Gloucester County School Board required their policies.

The district court dismissed the case. It reasoned that the districts were essentially seeking payment of money, which under the Tucker Act belongs in the Court of Federal Claims.

The Fourth Circuit majority disagreed, according to CRS. Claims that are "essentially contractual" go to the Court of Federal Claims, but statutory claims may proceed in district court. The panel found the districts' claims arose under Title IX rather than any contract or grant term, and that a declaration and an injunction are not relief rooted in contract.

Advertisement

One judge dissented. That judge viewed the core claim as a demand to restore advance payments, a right generated by the grants themselves.

The majority distinguished two 2025 Supreme Court interim orders, Department of Education v. California and National Institutes of Health v. American Public Health Association. Those cases involved plaintiffs asking a court to order payment under terminated grants. Justice Barrett's controlling concurrence in the second case sent grant-termination claims to the Court of Federal Claims and an APA challenge to agency guidance to district court.

CRS says that during the second Trump administration, federal agencies have suspended, terminated or threatened grant payments to other recipients over Title IX and Title VI compliance concerns. In some cases they did so without first following the statutes' procedural requirements. District courts have let APA challenges to those actions proceed, rejecting the argument that the Tucker Act removes their jurisdiction.

The Bottom Line

The First Circuit heard oral argument on Oct. 5 in Harvard University's appeal over terminated grants. The district court there granted Harvard summary judgment in part, treating its Title VI claims as statutory rather than contractual.

Congress could narrow or widen the Court of Federal Claims' jurisdiction, change the funding-termination procedures, or amend Title IX's judicial review provision. It could also leave the courts to settle the boundary.

Access the Legis1 platform for comprehensive political news, data, and insights

Spot something wrong? Report an issue with this article